• Pool

Amara Cay Resort Islamorada

Bliss by the sea

This beautiful laid back resort in Islamorada is perfect for a relaxing break.

Located in the heart of Florida's Sport Fishing Capital you won't be short of things to see and explore in the local area, from spending a day snorkeling along a shallow reef, chartering a boat and see what you can reel in, or simply unwinding in the carefree atmosphere of Islamorada and the Florida Keys.

Whether you choose to spend a lazy morning in a beach front hammock, take a dip in the Amara Cay's heated pool, sip a cocktail at Sparrows Rum Bar or enjoy fantastic dinner at Oltremare Ristorante you are sure to come home with some treasured memories. 

Hayes & Jarvis Rating
Average: 3.5 (1 vote)

Guide Price

£2,329 per person
Hotel Category
Trusted
Location Type
Beach
TripAdvisor Review
Tripadvisor rating 1732 Reviews
Florida Keys

Hotel highlights

  • Relax on the private beach
  • Cool off in the outdoor pool
  • Dine out at the Oltremare Ristorante
  • Take advantage of the complimentary shuttle service to explore the local area

Hotel Features

General Information

  • Check-in Time:
    16:00
  • Check-out Time:
    11:00
  • 110 rooms
  • Minimum age: 21
  • Floors have lift access: Yes

Main Facilities

  • Diving
  • Fitness facilities
  • Free parking
  • Outdoor pool
  • Watersports
  • Wifi

Accommodation Type

  • Boutique

Board Basis Options

  • Room Only

Hotel Location

Location Highlights

Amara Cay Resort Islamorada

  • Beach
  • Approx. 100 mins from Miami International Airport
1732 Reviews 81% of travellers recommended this hotel

Traveller ratings

  • Excellent 897
  • Very Good 526
  • Average 184
  • Poor 71
  • Terrible 55

What to Expect

  • Location
  • Sleep Quality
  • Rooms
  • Service
  • Value
  • Cleanliness

Reviews

Aug 17, 2019

Disappointed, not what it appears to be.

London, United Kingdom

This was a big disappointment. None of the staff were interested and our check in was almost rude. Everything seemed like effort for everyone. The room was ok but a bit small. Our son had the pull out sofa bed which was so uncomfortable. If he’d been older or we were staying for longer we’d have had to move. Lots of the sun beds at the pool were ripped and unusable. Lucky it was quiet or you’d never have got a seat. There is a man made beach here. Some sand thrown on a concrete dock. Very uncomfortable and not how it appears on the website. Lawn games were good and breakfast ok. The staff massively let this place down. Would not come again or recommend.
Aug 17, 2019

Had a great experience at Amara Cay Resort

First time at this resort. Found the accommodations excellent. Room appeared to be recently renovated. Staff was extremely welcoming and helpful. Our room overlooked the pool and beach and had a terrace if we wanted to sit outside. Pool was lovely and there was a huge tiki bar there where you could order drinks and food. The resort fee included bottled water, WiFi, kayaks and paddle boards. The WiFi was wonky in our room, only worked near the door. Wonder if the even numbered rooms had better reception. Definitely will return. Location of resort is convenient to restaurants and attractions. Besides the WiFi, the only other issue was the beach lounge chairs were ripped and needed replacing. Glad we found this place!
View all

You might also like these

Hilton Key Largo

Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo, Curio Collection by Hilton

Florida Keys

H&J Rating

Guide Price

£1,949 pp

Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo, Curio Collection by Hilton
Sheraton Suites Key West

Sheraton Suites Key West

Florida Keys

H&J Rating

Guide Price

£2,359 pp

Sheraton Suites Key West
Hawks Cay Resort Lagoon

Hawks Cay Resort

Florida Keys

H&J Rating

Guide Price

£2,019 pp

Hawks Cay Resort
The Reach Resort

The Reach Resort Key West

Florida Keys

H&J Rating

Guide Price

£2,359 pp

The Reach Resort Key West